Montauk Project

Montauk Project

Very positive (394 ratings)

  • Escape room
  • IRL

Mark as done to rate

YOUR MISSION: Infiltrate the area, locate the source of the mysterious incidents and bring back hard evidence.

  • 2-8
  • 60 mins
  • Hard
  • Not scary

Ratings

All ratings (394)

Very positive

Gameplay
Overwhelmingly positive
Atmosphere
Overwhelmingly positive
Customer service
Overwhelmingly positive

Reviews

@laurapoe
laurapoe

49 escape rooms

As others have noted, there’s some subtle/not so subtle Stranger Things theming woven into this experience, which is really fun. We enjoyed this room and only had a couple areas of minor confusion before we reached the last area. There are some super creative elements, especially inside the house. The last room is where we really struggled and got a little frustrated. This was through no fault of our GM, who did an awesome job trying to jump in to help. Of MyssTic’s three experiences, this one was my least favorite, but it’s absolutely worth doing if you’re there for either of their other rooms.

Gameplay
Atmosphere
Customer service

Meeka was such a fabulous GM — we really enjoyed their helpful nudges and chatting with them between games.

Particularly interesting or different

No

Story
Difficulty

Hard

We probably made this room harder than it should have been but we really struggled with a few of the puzzles, especially in the last area.

Game tech

Mechanical

Ideal number of players

4

Scary

Not scary

Minimum age

12

Was anything broken?

No

Live actors

No

Physically active

Not at all

Easy to find location

Yes

Parking

Limited

Sep 10, 2025 | Experienced Sep 9, 2025
@escapereb
escapereb

25 escape rooms

This was the final escape room at MyssTic that I hadn’t done and like the previous two, the set was absolutely incredible. Fully immersive room, with lots of opportunities to be surprised and delighted by the puzzles. There were a few puzzles that I enjoyed quite a bit less than others, but this room is really an excellent one so I have to give it a heart and a glowing review.

Sep 2, 2025
@dimitrash
dimitrash

142 escape rooms

most of the puzzles in this game, i had never seen before in other escape rooms. their originality made this game really awesome, and it’s great for stranger things fans like me 🤩

  • store/u/a30359d4-b54d-4f76-b2c1-78f2fd6857fc_75.jpg
Aug 16, 2025 | Experienced Aug 16, 2025

o

oddball

110 escape rooms

Really fun room. Legally distinct stranger things theme. The sets were engaging and unique. Very cinematic ending. When I played we accidentally skipped some steps towards the end but GM quickly helped us understand this error without detracting from game flow. A few times I wondered “is this really allowed?” and it was! I enjoy that out-of-the-box, boundary-pushing feeling 5/5

Aug 3, 2025
@dukefromearth
dukefromearth

29 escape rooms

Great game with a unique set. Four of us escaped way faster than we wanted to, but that’s likely just luck. MyssTic really does a phenomenal job creating an immersive environment. Such a great experience.

Gameplay
Atmosphere
Customer service
Particularly interesting or different

Yes

Apr 20, 2025 | Experienced Apr 19, 2025

j

jasinators

18 escape rooms

Very cool set design and pretty cool puzzles. I would come back here and try others. Recommend!

Gameplay
Atmosphere
Customer service
Mar 24, 2025
@PeytonWalton
PeytonWalton

151 escape rooms

This game was alright. It is definitely based on Stranger Things but it doesn’t require any prior knowledge of Stranger Things to be successful. The puzzles themselves are relatively simple but the connections in between puzzles aren’t always obvious. I felt as though the puzzles weren’t as exciting and involved as I would prefer. But I liked the way that the ending had a very clear objective and climax to the story!

Gameplay

This game was relatively linear and very doable with a party of 3. We didn’t always know what puzzle we were supposed to go to next (the connections weren’t always intuitive) so there were times that the gameplay lagged. The game master had to give us nudges in the right direction a couple of times because some of the flow lacked clarity.

Atmosphere

The game was cute and made sense for the theme. None of the set dressing absolutely blew my mind but it was well-done enough to feel immersive.

Customer service

The game master was kind and gave us nudges in the right direction when we needed it.

Particularly interesting or different

The game was different from other escape rooms I’ve done in the past BUT it was heavily based on stranger things. Considering this, I would say that the game was unique as an escape room but the plot itself was relatively familiar.

Story

We didn’t realize it was Stranger Things themed when we booked it but the connection was apparent once in the room. Having watched Stranger Things, the room felt very on theme. That being said, it would not hinder your ability to complete the room if you haven’t seen Stranger Things. If you aren’t familiar with the show, you might just need to pay more attention to the plot so that you understand what is going on.

Difficulty

Medium

The puzzles themselves were relatively easy. Making connections between the puzzles and figuring out what to do next was much harder in my opinion.

Game tech

There was a mix of physical locks and other means to unlock things. In my opinion, this room felt more mechanical than high tech.

Ideal number of players

3

3-4 would be an ideal amount for this game.

Scary

Spooky

Somewhere between not scary and spooky. There aren’t really any jump scares so any adult should be fine in this room. Younger participants may be intimidated by the latter half of the room.

Minimum age

10

On the condition that the kid visiting isn’t easily creeped out.

Was anything broken?

No

Live actors

No

Physically active

Not at all

A couple of puzzles required getting closer to the ground so at least 1 or 2 members of your party should be comfortable kneeling.

Accessibility

As long as 1-2 people in your party can kneel and get into smaller spaces, the room should be relatively accessible for participants with mobility restrictions (noting that some areas are still narrow and/or cramped). Additionally, one puzzle utilized color and another puzzle utilized sound.

Easy to find location

Yes

Parking

Limited

Jan 2, 2025 | Experienced Jan 1, 2025

l

lennox

25 escape rooms

Solid 3.5/5 - 4/5 stars. I think my expectations for this escape room were too high after having heard so many people recommend this and say that it's like the best escape room. It's not a bad room, and the rooms are immersive, but there were more physical puzzles (finding things, placing them in certain places, etc.) than brainy puzzles (riddles, etc.). I think I would've liked some more logic-based puzzles. Some of the puzzles seemed like they didn't connect with the story too well. I completed the room with a friend feeling a bit unchallenged. It also might've felt easier than other rooms I've tried because there are unlimited hints and the game master's voice did pop in a lot asking if we needed a hint, which made the experience feel less immersive. The game master was very sweet and attentive though. The climax of the escape room / story was a pretty cute idea, and I do appreciate that there was that "climax," which not all escape rooms have.

Gameplay
Atmosphere

A bit dark, so we had to use our phone camera

Customer service

Very friendly. Felt like a team player.

Particularly interesting or different

Yes

Story
Difficulty

Medium

Game tech

Mechanical

Good mix of both tech and mechanical puzzles, but leans more towards mechanical.

Ideal number of players

2

Scary

Not scary

Was anything broken?

No

Live actors

No

Physically active

Somewhat

Some puzzles require you to get on your knees or bend down to get into a small/short space

Accessibility

Not too accessible. Need to have good mobility, hearing, and sight

Easy to find location

Yes

Parking

Easy

Dec 24, 2024 | Experienced Dec 23, 2024

B

BoozeCluze

23 escape rooms

If you have to pick between rooms, choose this one. Some people were turned off by the stranger things theme; I’ve never seen an episode and it didn’t hamper my experience at all. So from the top, this room was just a collection of really clever puzzles. I wouldn’t say any of them were too hard, or made any thematic sense, but they were just an absolute joy to do. For example, putting X item on Y object shouldn’t progress the plot at all… but it was so much fun that I dot even care. The room was also very spacious and in New York, that’s a welcome asset. 9.5/10 and one of my top 5 I’ve ever done.

Gameplay

Really fun puzzles. None were too complex, but the point is to have fun; not to decipher code

Atmosphere

Great sets. Unlike corporate rooms, this one had lots of love and a bunch of detail

Customer service
Was anything broken?

No

Nov 10, 2024 | Experienced Nov 10, 2024

Showing results 1-10 of 54

Editorial

  • One of the top companies in New York City... what you’d want from a Stranger Things-inspired... game

    Room Escape Artist
Loading...