Bonus Fun Time Game Show does a great job of capturing the vibe of an era of game shows - it's an unusual, and (as promised) fun, theme. The set is great, and puzzles fit in well with the environment. However, if the theme doesn't speak to you, you might not see the appeal.
I think a major reason I'm not rating this a "love" is that I would have had a better time with fewer people. I had been told this game was better the more players you have, but I don't think it's true - like most games, the more players you have, the less any player gets to interact with. We played with 5, and I would have preferred 2-3. Having said that, if you're looking for a fun time for a group, this would probably fit the bill better than many games because of the theme and because it's decently parallelizable.
Particularly interesting or different
Yes
5 enthusiasts was more than enough, I would have rather played with fewer to see more of the game. 2-3 would probably be good.
The GM was in the room with us, though they didn't play that much of a role once the game was underway.
Physically active
Not at all
Accessibility
There is a dexterity puzzle
I had no problem parking on the street on a weekday morning, but could see it being harder if it were a more popular time.