The Postmaster's Riddle

The Postmaster's Riddle

Very positive (12 ratings)

  • Escape room
  • IRL

Mark as done to rate

After being hidden away for more than a century, the vision of Harriston’s original postmaster has come to fruition in this extraordinary puzzle room. Your goal? Beat the clock, climb the tower, and ring the bell for all to hear: there’s a new postmaster in town. More than 200 five-star online reviews claim that Escape the Old Post is unlike any other in Ontario. Ready to experience the Postmaster’s Riddle and try this compelling game for yourself?

  • 4-10
  • 90 mins
  • Not scary

Ratings

All ratings (12)

Very positive

Gameplay
Positive
Atmosphere
Positive
Customer service
Positive

Reviews

B

BillClintonFan99

52 escape rooms

Fantastic room. The design was spot on and nothing like what I’ve seen so far in other places in Ontario. The puzzles were amazing and very cleverly done. They made extremely good use of the space that they have. Best part was the games master who helped in useful ways only at parts where we were genuinely stuck. He also provided extra info/lore about the building and the town which was nice due to this room being in an actual historical building!

Gameplay
Atmosphere
Customer service
Easy to find location

Yes

Sep 1, 2025

o

oulfis

36 escape rooms

This was a real gem, well worth a long drive. It’s also definitely TWO escape rooms (or rather, one 3hr escape room)— our group of four serious escapers would have needed a lot more than our usual quotient of hints just to finish Part 1 in 90 minutes. (The GM very kindly let us stay over time to finish the very last puzzle.) Not all the puzzles are stunners but the room is chock full of hidden delights and some really unique interactions. We very gladly went back two days later, and had a blast! It somehow gets even more fun in the second half, and the climax is definitely satisfying.

Gameplay

Several of the puzzles had long "implementation" processes after you figured out the "trick" to them, which could feel like time-wasting when there was so much more-fun stuff to do; the more explicitly puzzle-y something was, the less "imbued with passion" it felt. But the fun of the more environmental gameplay made up for it.

Atmosphere

It’s not “immersive” in the sense of “like being on a movie set”, but the space is lovingly crafted and rewarding to explore -- lots of surprises!

Customer service

Particularly appreciated the staff being willing to run the game outside their usual scheduled times when one of our group got sick! We also got the impression that the GM likes to be very hands-on and helpful, especially with newbies.

Particularly interesting or different

Yes

I've never seen anything quite like this room -- it's clearly made by someone who LOVES experimental carpentry (but didn't have any other driving vision for the game). Definitely a memorable experience.

Story

The "story" here is, really, the story of the building itself -- we got lots of information about the history of the town post office, its former residents, and the restoration/construction process

Difficulty

Hard

Game tech

Mechanical

Ideal number of players

4

At least four just due to the quantity of tasks, and the room could certainly handle more.

Scary

Not scary

Was anything broken?

No

Live actors

No

Physically active

Somewhat

Several flights of stairs to get to the room, and then some ducking and climbing.

Accessibility

Not physically accessible at all (no elevator to the room). Not sure if the colour puzzles would be accessible for colour blindness.

Easy to find location

Yes

Parking

Easy

Jul 15, 2025 | Experienced Jul 16, 2025

t

tashwepps

14 escape rooms

Great gameplay and great team at the Old Post. The experience is like no other escape room. Truly a gem of Harriston. If you want a unique escape room experience with tons of twists and turns check this one out!

Gameplay
Atmosphere
Customer service
Particularly interesting or different

Yes

Dec 28, 2023

c

clar98jc

8 escape rooms

Amazing escape room the design and atmosphere were amazing! We were in a group of 8 and all experienced, we made it about 80% and had an amazing time! Staff were all awesome and we loved being able to get drinks

  • store/u/98c2b1aa-74d2-4364-bf4e-65ef99bd38bf_75.jpg
Gameplay
Atmosphere
Customer service
Scary

Not scary

Was anything broken?

No

Oct 21, 2023

Showing results 1-4 of 4

Loading...